C/360/2011 — Bhagyalaxmi Traders vs COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS(IMPORT)-MUMBAI

CUSTOMS, EXCISE AND SERVICE TAX APPELLATE TRIBUNAL MUMBAI

WEST ZONAL BENCH

CUSTOMS APPLICATION (MISC) NO: 85387 OF 2023 (on behalf of appellant) IN CUSTOMS APPEAL NO: 344 OF 2011

[Arising out of Order-in-Appeal No: 36 to 89/MCH/AC/Gr.III/2011 dated 25th February 2011 passed by the Commissioner of Customs (Appeals), Mumbai – I.]

Sakura Exports

552-58, Babu Genu Road, 1st Floor, Kalbadevi Road Mumbai - 400002

… Appellant versus

Commissioner of Customs (Import)

New Custom House, Ballard Estate, Mumbai - 400001

…Respondent

WITH

CUSTOMS APPLICATION (MISC) NO: 85383 OF 2023 IN CUSTOMS APPEAL NO: 345 OF 2011

Bhupendra Umbrell Mfg Co

21/23 Mahadev Shankar Seth Lane, Dadi Santuk Lane Chira Bazar, Mumbai - 400002

… Appellant versus

…Respondent

WITH

CUSTOMS APPLICATION (MISC) NO: 85361 OF 2023 IN CUSTOMS APPEAL NO: 352 OF 2011

2 C/344-345, 352, 360, 362, 369, 374, 384 & 386/2011

Bhagyalaxmi Exports

16, 3rd C, Gopal Baugh, Gazdhar Street Chira Bazar, Mumbai - 400002

… Appellant versus

…Respondent

WITH

CUSTOMS APPLICATION (MISC) NO: 85362 OF 2023 IN CUSTOMS APPEAL NO: 360 OF 2011

Bhagyalaxmi Exports

16, 3rd C, Gopal Baugh, Gazdhar Street Chira Bazar, Mumbai - 400002

… Appellant versus

…Respondent

WITH

CUSTOMS APPLICATION (MISC) NO: 85385 OF 2023 IN CUSTOMS APPEAL NO: 362 OF 2011

Neo Exports (Palghar)

Tiwari Industrial Estate, Boisar Road, Juna Palghar Palghar - 401404

… Appellant versus

…Respondent

85385 OF 2023 IN CUSTOMS APPEAL NO: 362 OF 2011

Neo Exports (Palghar)

Tiwari Industrial Estate, Boisar Road, Juna Palghar Palghar - 401404

… Appellant versus

…Respondent

3 C/344-345, 352, 360, 362, 369, 374, 384 & 386/2011
WITH

CUSTOMS APPLICATION (MISC) NO: 85386 OF 2023 IN CUSTOMS APPEAL NO: 369 OF 2011

M L Lodha International

59/2 MT Cloth Market, Vidhyalaya Bhawan Indore

… Appellant versus

…Respondent

WITH

CUSTOMS APPLICATION (MISC) NO: 85363 OF 2023 IN CUSTOMS APPEAL NO: 374 OF 2011

Shripal Textiles

16, 3rd C, Gopal Baugh, Gazdhar Street Chira Bazar, Mumbai - 400002

… Appellant versus

…Respondent

WITH

CUSTOMS APPLICATION (MISC) NO: 85388 OF 2023 IN CUSTOMS APPEAL NO: 384 OF 2011

B Chandan & Co

52/58, Babu Genu Road, Kalbadevi Road

… Appellant

4 C/344-345, 352, 360, 362, 369, 374, 384 & 386/2011
Mumbai - 400002 versus

…Respondent

WITH

CUSTOMS APPLICATION (MISC) NO: 85384 OF 2023 IN CUSTOMS APPEAL NO: 386 OF 2011

Sait Nagjee Purushotham & Co Pvt Ltd

94/96, Princess Street, Mumbai - 400002

… Appellant versus

…Respondent APPEARANCE: None for the appellants Shri Deepak Sharma, Deputy Commissioner (AR) for the respondent

CORAM:

HON’BLE MR C J MATHEW, MEMBER (TECHNICAL) HON’BLE MR AJAY SHARMA, MEMBER (JUDICIAL)

MISCELLANEOUS ORDER NO: 85508-85516/2025

DATE OF HEARING:

28/03/2025 DATE OF DECISION:
28/03/2025

PER: CORAM

AJAY SHARMA, MEMBER (JUDICIAL)

MISCELLANEOUS ORDER NO: 85508-85516/2025

DATE OF HEARING:

28/03/2025 DATE OF DECISION:
28/03/2025

PER: CORAM
On submission of Learned Authorized Representative that the

5 C/344-345, 352, 360, 362, 369, 374, 384 & 386/2011
appeal of Revenue against order1 of the Tribunal has since been withdrawn and refund has been granted, these applications are dismissed as infructuous. (Dictated and Pronounced in Open Court)

(AJAY SHARMA)
Member (Judicial) (C J MATHEW)
Member (Technical)

*/as

1 [final order no. A/573-625/13/CSTB/C-I dated 20th March 2013]